by Arthur Penn
A great deal of what can be seen today of Warton Church goes back to the Middle Ages, but there must have been many restorations along the way A very important one was carried out in the closing years of the 19th century, when we read that it was gradually falling into decay’ Earlier in the century there had been a scare about the safety of the south arcade, and under the guidance of Edward Paley, the well-known Lancaster architect, it had been rebuilt. But problems were many. Around 1800 the lead had been stripped from the roof to pay for repairs leaving the church in little better appearance than a barn, with rain falling on the heads of worshippers’ It had been customary for burials to be made in the floor of the church and. although this had ceased, there was a sanitary problem and the need for a concrete floor it is not clear what the pews were like, except that they were large square ones with straight backs and included the large square pew formerly owned by Sir George Middleton of Leighton Hall.
A Manchester architect, Mr. W Ball reported on the fabric in the late 1880s and painted a rather grim picture. The tower, he said, had been altered by the building up of several windows and of the arch into the church, and was in poor condition. He noted that changes had been made to the walls, and that on the north side of the nave ‘concealed in the present roof are five clerestory windows of simple design and square-headed but much mutilated’. The roof was in a bad state with all timbers more or less decayed, and the south wall was crooked and as much as nine inches out of perpendicular in places. The north aisle windows were decaying and needed replacement, the drainage was unsatisfactory and so on.
Under the leadership of the Rev. T H. Pain an appeal was launched for £2000 and in a short time three quarters of this sum was raised. But it was realised that more was needed, including the replacement of the pews, the replacement of the pulpit dated 1712, and the removal of the unsightly gallery at the west end which contained the organ. In those days the Washington connection was already thought significant and the church was ‘much visited in summer time by tourists and visitors’ on this account. A year or two before ‘a large piece of stucco fell from the outside wall, near where the west doorway must have been in past times and there was laid bare the arms of the Washingtons’. A great bazaar was held to raise money and the first day brought in £114.
It seems that the church must have been closed, pending repairs and in late 1889 a faculty was applied for to the Chancellor of the Manchester diocese. It was proposed to remove the table of the commandments, to remove the existing pulpit and replace it with a carved one, to take up the floor and relay it, to extend the chancel westward to its original boundary, to repew the church and to carry out other alterations.
A little bundle of press cuttings has been preserved recording in some detail what was done and a serious problem which nearly frustrated the whole project. One assumes that there must have been a lot of customary possession of pews, which was usual at that time and in many churches faculties issued by the diocesan consistory courts allotted pews to individuals and sometimes to properties. It seems that this had not happened in the case of Warton. In the late nineteenth century there was a growing feeling that pews ought to be open to all instead of being treated as a principal source of revenue. It would seem that it was proposed that when the new seats were provided they should be open.
Chancellor Christie received the application for a faculty from the vicar and churchwardens, but he also received objections from two local landowners, Colonel Marton, of Capernwray Hall and Mr. R T. Gillow of Leighton Hall. Mr. Gillow had succeeded to the estate in 1846 and would be about 83 at this time. Both objectors claimed to have ‘prescriptive rights’ in the church, which would be interfered with by the removal of their pews. The chancellor adjourned the court in January 1890 to see if an amicable arrangement could be made At the next meeting the objectors were represented by their solicitors, but W T. Sharp, the solicitor for the vicar and wardens was ill. The chancellor proposed that a faculty could be granted providing that Colonel Marton and Mr. Gillow were allowed the same rights as they had before and that they should have certain pews allotted to them in lieu of those to be removed. This placed Mr. Pain in a difficult position. The two objectors were not the only people who would lose prescriptive rights to pews, and these others would not agree to just two pew holders being treated specially. He thought to agree to this solution would mean a loss of financial contributions to the restoration work. He and the wardens contested that the objectors had any special rights and thought that as the Gillow family had not used the pew, as they’ were Roman Catholics, for 67 years any prescriptive rights would have been lost. Mr. Gillow’s only exercise of ownership was that he had for forty years let the pew to Messrs. Sharp, presumably the family of the vicar’s solicitor. This was held by the chancellor to be illegal both by ecclesiastical and common law. However the Chancellor quoted a case in which Lord Chief Justice Denham held that ‘in the case of a Roman Catholic owner they were not to look for the same amount of user that they would in an ordinary case’.
There was a flurry of activity to try to get the objectors to withdraw, as the whole operation was being held up. Mr. John Bolden called on Mr. Gillow and Mr. Edward Barton on Colonel Marton. The latter agreed not to oppose a faculty as he did not want to obstruct the church’s restoration, provided that his tenants were allocated accommodation. Mr. Bolden was less successful. Mr. Gillow did not show any evidence of title but simply made a bona fide claim. There was an exchange of letters in which Mr. Gillow claimed that the pew was an ancient appurtenance of his house and his only motive was a sense of duty in defending the rights of property of which he was tenant for life. According to Chancellor Christie the bona fide claim was enough to oust the jurisdiction of his court and bar the granting of a faculty. The question of rights could only be established in the Queen’s Bench. Neither side was prepared for this and the suggestion was then made that counsel’s opinion should be sought but Mr. Gillow would not agree to this.
In this impasse a public meeting of the parishioners was held on 23rd April in the grammar schoolroom to report. The Vicar and Mr. Barton described the negotiations and a resolution was passed unanimously instructing the committee to have the church as it was put into a fit slate for occupation so that it may again be used for divine service without further delay
The reports do not tell us what happened next, but the work must have eventually been put in hand, because a column in the Westmorland Gazette for 6 May 1893 is among the cuttings reporting the re-opening of Warton Church. This tells how the interior work was financed by £1000 of subscriptions and Sales of Work. The Ecclesiastical Commissioners as the tithe owners of the parish undertook to reconstruct and furnish the chancel at their own cost Mr. Dawson of Aldcliffe Hall promised a new pulpit This was placed where the Leighton Hall pew had formerly been, but many years later was moved to its present position on the south side. Other offers were made of specific items Messrs Hatch and Son were the contractors undertaking to construct seats for 500 persons and to remove the gallery and the organ. The new pews were of plain oak and a carved reredos and communion table were provided £60 was spent on improving the organ which was done by Mr. Wadsworth. The total work cost some £3000 and was completed by Christmas 1892 The Leighton coats of arms were placed in one of the new pews, but all seats were now free, it seems that no prescriptive rights were recognised.
On a Thursday in May 1893 a very large congregation and half a dozen clergy took part in the opening service at which Dr. Ware the Suffragan Bishop of Barrow-in-Furness, preached.
Published in Mourholme Magazine Issue 38 2000
